Liberté, Egalité, but Ixnay Fraternité

Today is Bastille Day, the day in 1789 when Parisian mobs turned the world upside down. La Fête Nationale celebrates the storming of the Bastille Saint-Antoine prison and the start of the French Revolution, which ended the Ancien Régime and challenged the divine right of kings to rule. Subsequently, Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette were executed by guillotine in 1793. Their son and heir to the throne, Louis-Charles, died from malnourishment and tuberculosis several years later at the age of ten.

Les Gilets Jaunes

Robespierre, the Jacobin revolutionary leader and butt of many jokes by me about the importance of execution in business, also lost his head but not before having half his jaw blown off during his arrest. This was a fitting end for the man who orchestrated the Reign of Terror through a radical ideology intended to replace the monarchy with a “Republic of Virtue,” which is like announcing that the beheadings will continue until people are kinder to each other.

As a result, nearly 17,000 people were executed throughout France between the summers of 1793 and 1794, which was a good time to be a guillotine sales rep. As Walter Duranty, a New York Times correspondent and apologist for Joseph Stalin, observed a century and a half later, “you can’t make an omelet without breaking a few eggs.”

We may have arrived at another egg-breaking moment in history. This one involves the French national motto of “Liberté, Egalité, Fraternité,” which comes from a 1790 speech by Robespierre. There are two sides to this egg breaking: those espousing liberté and those who demand egalité. The problem is that both cancel out fraternité. This makes it harder to celebrate Bastille Day, although with all the bloodletting that ensued after the original event, it’s probably just as well.

Those on the liberté side represent the Lockean tradition of God-given, inalienable rights. These include the rights to life, worship, expression, and assembly. Individual liberty derives from natural law and is expressed through democratic institutions like private property and capitalism. All persons are free by their nature as human beings, in the eyes of God, and before the law.

A popular expression of this viewpoint used to be: “I disagree with what you say but will defend to the death your right to say it.” You don’t hear that as much anymore.

Those who favor egalité demand equal representation and outcomes for all, especially for those who have been oppressed historically (e.g., women, minorities, LGBT). To make amends for past injustices and to adjust for current inequalities, they want to give preferential treatment to these groups until all distinctions by gender, race, and sexual orientation disappear from the public sphere. And, as much as possible, the private one as well.

This reminds me of Jerry Seinfeld’s complaint about efforts to make stand-up more inclusive as if comedy were a topic for the United Nations. I’m not sure about the United Nations, but I do wish comics were less belligerent.

These two sides have taken their principles and hijacked them. The problem is that when you increase one, you automatically decrease the other. When you make everyone equal in every way, you curtail freedom. Unchecked freedom can lead to the greed witnessed in the 2008 financial crisis.

Conservatives are sensitive to the threat of ideology. George Orwell and Aldous Huxley have become their patron saints. Progressives want to wipe out intolerance, some bragging with a straight face that they are “intolerant of intolerance.” True to their Marxist roots, they have no problem using violence to achieve their ends as seen recently in Portland.

But what of fraternité? Who will lay demagoguery aside for the good of the whole? Don’t look to the President. Meanwhile, there are enough Democrats running to replace him to have a softball game, yet most act like petulant children. And the mainstream media have given up journalism in favor of public relations, their stars turning into caricatures of themselves. Only their devotees take them seriously anymore.

Yet, fraternité is a fragile thing. It requires good will and the ability to sacrifice for others so the entire country–sea to shining sea–can prosper. Without it, liberté and egalité consume each other and end in terror. Let’s hope history does not repeat itself.

Feature image by Pierre Herman on Unsplash, top by Ella_87 from Pixabay, middle by Colin Schmitt from Pexels. For more, go to Robert Brancatelli. The Brancatelli Blog is a member of The Free Media Alliance, which promotes “alternatives to software, culture and hardware monopolies.”


  1. By the way, regarding your mid-week reading suggestions: I’ve already read The Gringo and Laura Fedora. I really enjoyed the travails of travel and culture, the unique characters, and the rich humor. Waiting for the next…

    1. Really? Wow. That’s a lot of inner turmoil and perversion to read about so fast. I have to go back to Guatemala to finish the trilogy. I don;t know when that will be…Try Nine Lives. You may like it. It’s autobiographical, except I lie a lot.

  2. By the way, regarding your midweek reading suggestions…I’ve already read two of the three: The Gringo and Laura Fedora. I enjoyed both for the travails of travel and culture, the original characters, and the humor:). I’ll be on the lookout for your next…

  3. Yes, the balance between the individual and the whole, our brotherhood at all levels: family, work, country, and our boat in the universe, earth. It is difficult, Robert, because someone must start. This start often means tremendous sacrifice and death, in all of its forms. Additionally, the beginning is often very flawed and full of mistakes. Many beginnings end badly for those starting out to be and do better. Some lose everything, well beyond the material forms: faith, hope, trust, family, home, and…
    (Delayed response due to some rough weather.). Thank you, Robert:)

      1. Sorry, Robert. Kind of looking back, experiencing some of the results of the many things I wished I had done better in my life. I think we all have these moments, right? But…there are many courageous people of faith and kindness that keep walking, and so do we, right?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this:
Verified by MonsterInsights